Looking for a PaymentPutty Alternative?
PaymentPutty handles AB-1263 on BigCommerce. ShipToVerified does that — and works on WooCommerce, custom stacks, and across multiple regulated industries. Here's how the two compare on features, flexibility, and total cost.
ShipToVerified vs PaymentPutty
A direct look at platform capabilities and pricing.
| Feature | ShipToVerified | PaymentPutty |
|---|---|---|
| AB-1263 Compliance | ✓Yes | ✓Yes |
| BigCommerce Support | ✓Native | ✓Yes |
| WooCommerce Support | ✓Plugin available | ✗No |
| REST API for Custom Stacks | ✓Full REST API | ✗BigCommerce API integrations available (standalone REST API for non-BigCommerce platforms not confirmed) |
| Multi-Industry Support | ✓Firearms, cannabis, alcohol, high-value | ✗Firearms only |
| AI-Powered Verification | ✓AI document extraction | ✗Manual document upload |
| Customer Self-Remediation | ✓Yes — customer resolves on their own | ✗No |
| Embeddable Widget | ✓Yes | ✗No |
| Monthly Fee | ✓$0/month | ✗$300/month |
| One-Time Setup Fee | ✓$1,000 | ✗$3,999 |
| Per-Verification Cost | ✓$1.00 | ✗Included in flat monthly rate |
The Real Cost Comparison
PaymentPutty charges $300/month + a $3,999 implementation fee. ShipToVerified is $1 per verification + $1,000 setup. At lower volumes, ShipToVerified costs less. At higher volumes, PaymentPutty's flat rate wins on price — but you're also giving up WooCommerce support, API access, and multi-industry flexibility.
| Volume | ShipToVerified (Year 1) | PaymentPutty (Year 1) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
250 orders/mo 3,000 orders/yr | $4,000 $1,000 setup + $3,000 verifications | $7,599+ $3,999 setup + $3,600/yr subscription | STV wins |
500 orders/mo 6,000 orders/yr | $7,000 $1,000 setup + $6,000 verifications | $7,599+ $3,999 setup + $3,600/yr subscription | STV wins |
1,000 orders/mo 12,000 orders/yr | $13,000 $1,000 setup + $12,000 verifications | $7,599+ $3,999 setup + $3,600/yr subscription | PP cheaper* |
2,000 orders/mo 24,000 orders/yr | $25,000 $1,000 setup + $24,000 verifications | $7,599+ $3,999 setup + $3,600/yr subscription | PP cheaper* |
* At 1,000+ orders/month, PaymentPutty's flat rate is cheaper on a pure cost basis. However, PaymentPutty provides no WooCommerce support, no REST API, no multi-industry coverage, and no embeddable widget. If any of those matter to your business, the calculus changes. PaymentPutty Year 1 total assumes $3,999 setup + $3,600 subscription ($300 × 12).
At 500 orders/month — ShipToVerified saves you $599 in Year 1
ShipToVerified: $1,000 setup + $6,000 verifications = $7,000
PaymentPutty: $3,999 setup + $3,600 subscription = $7,599
And ShipToVerified drops to zero setup cost in Year 2 — just $6,000 for 6,000 verifications. PaymentPutty still costs $3,600/year in subscription fees regardless of volume.
Beyond BigCommerce
PaymentPutty is built exclusively for BigCommerce. That's a hard dependency — one that limits your options now and constrains you in the future. ShipToVerified works across platforms by design.
WooCommerce — Where PaymentPutty Stops
PaymentPutty is a BigCommerce-only solution. If you run WooCommerce, you're locked out entirely. ShipToVerified offers a WooCommerce plugin that brings the same compliance workflow to the world's most popular eCommerce platform.
REST API for Every Stack
Running a headless storefront, a custom-built checkout, or a proprietary OMS? ShipToVerified exposes a full REST API so compliance verification integrates anywhere. PaymentPutty provides API integrations within the BigCommerce ecosystem but does not appear to offer a standalone REST API for non-BigCommerce platforms.
Future-Proof Your Compliance Stack
If you migrate platforms, add a second storefront, or expand to new regulated categories, PaymentPutty can't follow you. ShipToVerified's multi-platform architecture means your compliance layer stays in place regardless of what your commerce stack looks like.
ShipToVerified works on BigCommerce natively, WooCommerce via plugin, and any other platform via REST API — with the same compliance workflow, the same audit trail, and the same $1/verification pricing.
“10/10 Recommend”
J. Hernandez — AR15Discounts.com
Request a Demo
See how ShipToVerified can automate your shipping compliance workflow. We'll walk you through the product and answer any questions.
What to expect:
- 1Quick intro call
15-minute overview of your current workflow
- 2Live product demo
See the verification flow in action
- 3Custom implementation plan
Integration timeline and next steps
Prefer to reach out directly?
info@shiptoverified.com